CELPIP Speaking Task 5: Comparing & Persuading (Band 7-10)
Learn the art of comparing two options and persuading someone to choose one. Learn to present balanced comparisons, highlight advantages, and use persuasive language effectively to score Band 7-10.
What They Test
Understanding the assessment criteria helps you deliver exactly what examiners are looking for.
Balanced Comparison
Your ability to fairly compare both options, acknowledging strengths and weaknesses of each before making a recommendation.
Persuasive Reasoning
Providing clear, logical reasons why your chosen option is better, considering factors like value, practicality, and benefits.
Comparison Language
Using appropriate comparative structures, linking words, and phrases to highlight differences and advantages effectively.
Clear Recommendation
Ending with a strong, clear recommendation that summarizes why your chosen option is the better choice.
Template Phrases
Ready-to-use expressions for comparing options and persuading effectively.
Opening & Acknowledging Both Options
- "I've looked at both options, and I'd recommend..."
- "After comparing A and B, I think..."
- "Both options have their merits, but I'd choose..."
Comparing Options
- "Option A is... whereas Option B is..."
- "In contrast to..., this option offers..."
- "While... has..., ... provides..."
- "The main difference is that..."
Highlighting Advantages
- "The main advantage is that..."
- "What makes this better is..."
- "This option is superior because..."
- "Value-wise, this offers better..."
Persuasive Closing
- "For these reasons, I strongly recommend..."
- "Let's go with... because..."
- "I believe... is the better choice for..."
Sample Answer (30s prep + 60s)
See how a Band 7-10 comparison and persuasion response sounds with proper structure and reasoning.
Scenario:
Compare two options for a pet: Option A is a cat, Option B is a golden retriever. Persuade someone to choose one based on their lifestyle (busy schedule, small apartment).
Opening & Recommendation:
"I've looked at both options, and I'd recommend Option A, the cat, for your city routine. Both pets have their merits, but given your busy schedule and small apartment, a cat would be the more practical choice."
Comparing Options:
"First, cats are independent, so an eight-hour workday is fine—you won't feel guilty about missed walks. In contrast, a golden retriever needs 60-90 minutes of daily walks and training, plus regular grooming and company, which would be challenging with your schedule. While the dog is loving and loyal, a cat's space needs are much smaller; a studio apartment works perfectly, and daily care is just feeding, litter maintenance, and short play sessions."
Value & Benefits:
"Value-wise, cats cost less per month in food and vet care, and they typically live longer, so you get years of companionship with lower upkeep. The main advantage of choosing a cat is that it fits your lifestyle—commuting, late classes, and limited space—while still providing affection and companionship when you're home."
Persuasive Closing:
"For these reasons, I strongly recommend the cat. It's practical, affordable, and still affectionate. Let's go with Option A and set up a scratching post and litter box this weekend."
Why This Response Scores High:
- Fairly compares both options before making a recommendation
- Uses appropriate comparison language (whereas, in contrast, while)
- Provides specific, practical reasons relevant to the person's situation
- Considers value, practicality, and lifestyle fit
- Ends with a clear, persuasive recommendation
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Learn from these frequent errors that lower scores on CELPIP Speaking Task 5.
Mistake 1: Not Comparing Both Options Fairly
Jumping straight to your recommendation without acknowledging both options shows poor analytical thinking.
Weak:
"I'd choose Option A. It's better."
Strong:
"I've looked at both options, and while Option B has some advantages, I'd recommend Option A because it offers better value, fits your lifestyle, and provides more practical benefits for your specific situation."
Mistake 2: Giving Opinions Without Supporting Reasons
Simply stating which option you prefer isn't enough—you need to explain why with specific, relevant reasons.
Weak:
"Option A is good. I like it better."
Strong:
"Option A is superior because it costs less per month, requires minimal maintenance, and fits perfectly in a small space. In contrast, Option B, while attractive, needs more space and higher ongoing costs, which would be challenging given your current situation."
Mistake 3: Ignoring the Other Option Completely
High-scoring responses acknowledge the other option's strengths before explaining why your choice is better.
Tip: Use phrases like "While Option B has...", "In contrast to...", or "Although... offers..., ... provides..." to show balanced comparison and sophisticated language.
Mistake 4: Weak Closing Without Clear Recommendation
Ending without a strong, clear recommendation weakens your persuasive argument.
Weak:
"So, that's what I think about the options."
Strong:
"For these reasons, I strongly recommend Option A. It's the better choice for your needs, offering the best combination of value, practicality, and suitability. Let's go with Option A."
Mini Quiz
Test your understanding of CELPIP Speaking Task 5.
1. What is the primary purpose of CELPIP Speaking Task 5?
2. Which approach is most effective for Task 5?
3. What makes a strong persuasive response?
Ready to Practice Task 5?
Put your comparison and persuasion skills into action with our interactive CELPIP Speaking exercises.